HomepageISTEEdSurge
Skip to content
ascd logo

Log in to Witsby: ASCD’s Next-Generation Professional Learning and Credentialing Platform
Join ASCD
July 1, 2024
Vol. 81
No. 9

Adapting Discussions to Unpredictable Attendance

author avatar
How can teachers turn student unpreparedness into participation?

Instructional StrategiesEquity
Overlapping speech bubbles connecting in a circle, symbolizing students coming together to participate in discussion in diverse ways
Credit: incomible / iStock
I began my teaching career at a school where, for many reasons both in and outside of their control, a lot of students struggled to come to class. This meant that, on any given day, I had no idea which students would be there. I could plan few, if any, discussions around the assumption that the same students who were there yesterday would be there today. This also meant that few valued resources, like books, went home with kids because our school was not particularly confident that it would ever get them back.
So, every day and every discussion had to make sense within the context of a single class period. I could neither assume prior knowledge about a text nor depend on the ability to follow up with a student the next day. This is no longer my teaching reality, but I learned a career-shaping lesson about class conversations that first year: always be ready for nobody to have done “the reading.” With this, our discussions can survive in the face of absenteeism that can be both unpredictable and ­pervasive.
Practically, this means that class discussions benefit from teachers giving students immediate access to relevant information and key terms before we start prompting. Some kids might not need this information, as they come to the moment prepared. Others, for whatever reason, do not, and so we face the choice to either leave them behind or to give them just enough of a grounding to participate. If our pride gets involved, we might choose the former. This is understandable. But it too often is an illogical choice. If kids do not have enough information to participate, awkward silence might not be the only consequence. These kids might become a classroom management problem. And what’s the point? It’s not like kids who enter a ­conversation unprepared will suddenly start doing their homework tonight out of ­embarrassment. We cannot fill students’ return to school with “gotcha” moments meant to shame them into attending.

Making the Most of Discussion Time

There are a couple of ways to ground students in the information being discussed. Unfortunately, both of these strategies eat at valuable discussion time, so we have to choose wisely. First, we can read aloud the portion of the text that will be discussed. If we want the class to discuss one moment in an entire scene, we could read aloud just that moment, even if it’s only one of 25 assigned pages of their homework. (I am a fan of making this reading interactive, having kids “act out” or do dramatic voices.) This roughly three-minute investment is not just for the kids who didn’t read. It’s for the kids who “read” while doing their chores or playing video games or watching TV. It’s for the kids who “read” at 2:00 a.m. with their eyes half-closed or in the lunch period before class. Everyone could always use a review. Any veteran ELA or history teacher can remember moments when students gasped at something that happened in the reading, and when asked why they were surprised, the students said some version of, “I swear that I read it! I just didn’t remember that happening!” I teach students Lord of the Flies, and every year, when Simon dies, students who have not read attentively are ­surprised as I review this passage aloud:
At once the crowd [of kids] . . . poured down the rock, leapt on the beast [Simon], screamed, struck, bit, tore. There were no words, and no movements but the tearing of teeth and claws.
They say, “Wait, they ate him?” Giggling, I say, “In a way, yup!” And suddenly, engagement is boosted.

We cannot fill students’ return to school with 'gotcha' moments meant to shame them into attending.

Author Image

Second, we can give students a quick summary that might only take a few seconds. It helps if we do a little bit of “selling” the reading. We might just say, “So, in last night’s reading, ___ got in an argument with ___ and it was wild!” From here, we could either tell the class what happened or ask for volunteers to do so. It might be tough to figure out when to ask for volunteers. Awkward silences are not always bad—­sometimes students just need time to think or to work up the courage to raise their hands. But these awkward silences can be destructive when they follow simple requests, like asking kids what happened in the reading. We face the temptation to passive-aggressively extend the silence, thinking we are embarrassing unprepared students. And I’ve seen students do the same, wanting to punish an overeager teacher. Again, what’s the point? Just tell them what happened! Now we can ask our interesting prompts and get going.

Reframing Accountability

Just to be clear, I am not against accountability. I’m actually pretty old-school about quizzes, using them for just about every take-home reading. Students who don’t do the reading will fail these quizzes. Students who don’t do the reading will write bad essays. They will probably not get a good grade in my class. But class ­discussions have got to be different. Everyone gets to engage with the ideas if they have even the slightest motivation to do so. Kids who didn’t read might not get as much out of a conversation as kids who did. But they should get something. Discussions should not just be another way for students who miss school to feel excluded from the community that we’ve built.
Put simply, great classroom discussions should give students who are not motivated by quiz grades a reason to earnestly engage with the content. (And even, with wild hope, to come to school!) It’s a similar feeling to a friend making us watch an episode of their favorite HBO series. We need just enough basic information to root ourselves in the episode that we are watching. And if that episode is entertaining enough, we’re more likely to watch future episodes. We might just go home and stream the show from the beginning.

Reflect & Discuss

➛ Kay suggests great discussions can do more than hold students accountable. How can classwide discussions authentically motivate and engage students?

➛ What’s one strategy you could use to not make class discussions a “gotcha” moment for unprepared students?

End Notes

Golding, W. (1954). Lord of the Flies. Faber and Faber, p. 153.

Matthew R. Kay is a proud product of Philadelphia's public schools and a founding teacher at Science Leadership Academy. He is also the founder and co-director of Philly Slam League, a nonprofit organization that shows young people the power of their voices through weekly spoken word competitions and workshops.

Kay is the author of the bestselling Not Light, but Fire: How to Lead Meaningful Race Conversations in the Classroom, as well as the co-author of We're Gonna Keep on Talking: How to Lead Meaningful Race Conversations in the Elementary Classroom and Answers to Your Biggest Questions About Teaching Middle and High School ELA.

Learn More

ASCD is a community dedicated to educators' professional growth and well-being.

Let us help you put your vision into action.
Related Articles
View all
undefined
Instructional Strategies
Teaching on a Higher Note
Tara Laskowski
2 weeks ago

undefined
4 Tools for Doable Differentiation
Paul Emerich France
2 weeks ago

undefined
Thriving in the Zone of Productive Struggle
Lee Ann Jung
2 weeks ago

undefined
Reframing Student Self-Talk
Jennifer Mangels
2 weeks ago

undefined
Teaching Up to Help Generation Alpha Flourish
Yvette Jackson & Linda Montes et al.
2 weeks ago
Related Articles
Teaching on a Higher Note
Tara Laskowski
2 weeks ago

4 Tools for Doable Differentiation
Paul Emerich France
2 weeks ago

Thriving in the Zone of Productive Struggle
Lee Ann Jung
2 weeks ago

Reframing Student Self-Talk
Jennifer Mangels
2 weeks ago

Teaching Up to Help Generation Alpha Flourish
Yvette Jackson & Linda Montes et al.
2 weeks ago
From our issue
Cover of issue with green background, blue fading backpacks symbolizing "absence," and text that reads: "From Absent to Engaged"
From Absent to Engaged
Go To Publication